On a whim this week I bought I.M. Healthy’s SoyNut butter, a peanut butter alternative made with roasted soynuts. It has 30% less fat than regular peanut butter, uses non-GMO soybeans, and is made in a peanut-free facility (great for folks that are deathly allergic to peanuts). It comes in original, honey, unsweetened, and chocolate varieties, and each one is available in creamy or chunky (except for the chocolate).
I tried a jar of the creamy original flavor and was amazed by how tasty it was. It has the exact same color and consistency of creamy peanut butter and its flavor, while not exactly matching, is extremely good. Pricewise, a regular sized jar cost me $3.99 at Giant. It tastes great with jelly or alone.